Countertenor Anthony Roth Costanzo Publishes Memoir "Countertenor" With Companion Album
Countertenor Anthony Roth Costanzo publishes a memoir and album titled "Countertenor," covering castrati history, thyroid cancer and Opera Philadelphia's $11 ticket experiment that sold out a season.

Programme
- Anthony Roth Costanzo published a memoir and companion album titled "Countertenor."
- Alessandro Moreschi's 1904 recording is the only known recording of a castrato.
- Opera Philadelphia sold out its season within three weeks after making every ticket $11 or pick-your-price.
- The $11 season drew 69% first-time ticket buyers and 67% audience members under 45.
- Costanzo rebuilt his voice after thyroid cancer surgery and won the Metropolitan Opera competition the following year.
By Tom Whitfield
Anthony Roth Costanzo, general director and president of Opera Philadelphia, has published a memoir titled "Countertenor," accompanied by an album of the same name featuring songs written for castrati and countertenors, contemporary music, pop covers and a Hawaiian song.
Costanzo laid out the book's scope and his career in a lengthy interview with Terry Gross on NPR's Fresh Air. He has sung with the Metropolitan Opera, including the title role in Philip Glass's "Akhnaten" about the ancient Egyptian pharaoh, and he serves as artistic director of Carnegie Hall's SongStudio.
What does the memoir actually cover?
A central thread is the history of the castrati — thousands of boys castrated before puberty from the 16th century onward so they could sing high parts in the Catholic Church, which barred women from singing. The practice fell out of favor around the end of the 18th century.
Costanzo's account is unflinching. "Because it was forbidden by the church, all the castration had to happen behind closed doors, sometimes in the back of barbershops," he told Gross. The testicles were crushed rather than cut, he said, to avoid bleeding, and mothers invented cover stories — "a popular one was, my son was bitten by a wild boar."
The church forbade the act but employed the results. Castrati sang in the Sistine Chapel Choir up until the 20th century and became, in Costanzo's words, "the rock stars of their era — the highest-paid singers." Only a small percentage — he puts it at 10% — of castrated boys reached superstar status.
The sole surviving recording of a castrato is Alessandro Moreschi, captured in 1904 at roughly age 40. Costanzo described hearing "pain in it somehow, in the tone, in the sort of acrid sound that he has."
A caveat follows the star narrative: composers wrote extremely long lines for castrati because their physiology — more cartilaginous bones, expandable rib cages — allowed it. Today's countertenors, Costanzo noted, cannot physically match that capacity.
The voice itself
Costanzo demonstrated on air the mechanics of his register, explaining that two involuntary muscle sets control chest and head voice, and that "the only thing that controls the muscles in your throat, strangely, is your imagination." He sang both parts — the Count and Susanna — of a duet from Mozart's "The Marriage of Figaro," recorded consecutively, jumping between registers.
Gross admitted she initially assumed a second singer performed the low part. "I couldn't imagine them being by the same person," she said.
The Hawaiian song "E Mama E," included on the album, exploits the vocal "crack" between registers that classical training usually smooths over. In Hawaiian tradition, Costanzo explained, singers use that break "as a kind of way of expressing something. It can be pain, it can be love." He framed opera singing itself as cathartic: the Metropolitan Opera, nearly 4,000 seats, uses no microphones, demanding an almost Olympic effort — "a cultivated scream."
Thyroid cancer and rebuilding the voice
Costanzo recounted that a singing teacher noticed him turning his head to the left while singing and suggested a thyroid check. The diagnosis was thyroid cancer. Surgery near the vocal cords risked his voice; he chose to operate, needed a second surgery, and rebuilt the voice from scratch with his teacher Joan — two minutes of gentle exercises daily at 9:45 a.m. The following year he won the Metropolitan Opera competition.
Joan's counsel on critics was memorable: "Anthony, you must remember that critics are like virgins telling whores how to make love."
The business of saving a company
When Costanzo took over Opera Philadelphia, the company faced a cash crisis: 12 weeks to raise $4 million or go bankrupt, with only about 30% of season tickets sold.
His answer was radical pricing. Every ticket for every seat became $11 or pick-your-price. Within three weeks the entire season sold out — he believes the only American opera company to do so before opening. The audience data: 69% first-time ticket buyers, 67% under 45.
The marketing was deliberately unglamorous. For $5,000 he bought ads on Philadelphia's Big Belly trash cans — a month's purchase that stayed up for a year. On Grindr, a roughly $1,000 ad buy reaches 500,000 people.
Costanzo also described voicing "Plant Man" in the launch commercial for the purple M&M, a campaign that became a Tucker Carlson talking point on Fox News. "It sunk Purple, the purple M&M, and, in fact, it was a prob, Girl," Costanzo said. "If I can enter the zeitgeist with an operatic voice, then I've really reached new heights."
The memoir connects the castrati history to present debates. "As distant as the castrati seem, the broader issues they raise feel preternaturally relevant — gender, sexuality, misogyny, religious hypocrisy, ethical consent," he writes.
What does this change for opera? Costanzo's Philadelphia experiment argues that price and perception, not repertoire, are the barrier — and his season sold out on that bet.
Source: NPR Arts
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,581 articles



