Eurovision organisers challenge cuts to Malaysian broadcast
Footage cited by The Guardian shows TV3 replacing Vice Ganda with a scoreboard and cutting drag performers. The EBU will ask Voxovation and TV3 for answers.

Programme
- The first Eurovision Song Contest Asia final took place in Bangkok and was won by the Philippines’ Carmelle.
- TV3 showed only a scoreboard when the international feed showed Vice Ganda awarding Aina Abdul the Philippine jury’s maximum 12 points.
- The EBU will ask Voxovation to establish with TV3 why Malaysia altered the broadcast.
- Malaysian law can punish oral and anal sex with up to 20 years in prison.
- In May 2018, the EBU ended its Mango TV partnership after dropped Irish and Albanian entries and a blurred rainbow flag.
By Marcus Bennett
Vice Ganda awarded the Philippine jury’s maximum 12 points to Aina Abdul in footage cited by The Guardian. TV3 viewers in Malaysia saw only a scoreboard. The first Eurovision Song Contest Asia final took place in Bangkok, where the Philippines’ Carmelle won.
Circulating footage documented the first of two cuts during voting in Saturday’s final. Eurovision’s organisers said the broadcast had apparently removed LGBTQ+ imagery and people from the show. In the first cut, Vice Ganda, the Philippines’ spokesperson, disappeared as the national jury awarded its points.
The Guardian described the announcement of a national jury’s points as one of the Eurovision final’s most visible roles. Each country’s spokesperson appears in turn to reveal how its jury has ranked the other entries.
The Guardian reported that Vice Ganda is gay and identifies as non-binary. The comedian is among the biggest stars on Philippine television and has fronted the country’s most watched daytime show. He has campaigned for LGBTQ+ acceptance at home.
In separate footage reviewed by The Guardian, the show’s opening number showcased Thai culture through drag performers on street food carts, but a wide shot taken during rehearsals replaced that sequence.
Eurovision fans accused the channel of “censorship”, The Guardian reported. The Guardian could not independently review TV3’s broadcast because its livestream is no longer available online.
How are Eurovision and Voxovation responding?
The European Broadcasting Union (EBU), the alliance of public broadcasters that owns Eurovision, will write to Voxovation, the company producing the Asian contest under licence. It will ask the producer to establish with Malaysian broadcaster TV3 why the broadcast changed.
Martin Green, the director of the Eurovision song contest, said:
We are surprised and disappointed to learn that the broadcast of Eurovision Song Contest Asia was altered in Malaysia.
We take this matter seriously and will be writing to Voxovation, the producers of the show, to seek clarification and ask them to establish with Malaysian broadcaster TV3 why this happened.
This appears to be isolated to the Malaysian broadcast of the show, and all other transmissions were not altered.
Voxovation said in a statement that it was aware of the concerns raised and was “looking into the matter with the broadcaster to establish the circumstances … We are working with the Malaysian broadcaster to make sure this doesn’t happen again.”
Neither the EBU nor Voxovation said whether the contest’s participation agreement required broadcasters to carry the show unedited. Neither disclosed what consequences would follow if a broadcaster did not. The Guardian has asked Media Prima, Malaysia’s largest media group and TV3’s owner, for comment.
How do the contest’s values square with national law?
The Guardian asked before Saturday’s final how the EBU’s commitment to its values squared with the laws in Malaysia and Bangladesh, the other competing country where same-sex relations are criminalised. The EBU’s head of communications, Dave Goodman, said the contest’s values were “non-negotiable”.
Malaysia has some of Asia’s harshest anti-LGBTQ+ laws. Oral and anal sex are punishable by up to 20 years in prison.
The Guardian reported that rights groups have warned of a hardening climate. It documented these enforcement actions:
- In November last year, authorities raided a men-only spa in Kuala Lumpur and detained more than 200 men. No charges followed.
- In 2022, police raided an LGBTQ+ Halloween party in the capital and arrested 20 people.
How has Eurovision handled earlier censorship?
In May 2018, the EBU terminated its partnership with the Chinese streaming service Mango TV after it dropped the Irish and Albanian entries and blurred a rainbow flag in the audience, saying such censorship was not in line with its “values of universality and inclusivity”.
TV3 has faced pressure over LGBTQ+ visibility before, The Guardian reported. In 2023, a festival appearance by the British band the 1975 led to cancellation.
The band’s singer criticised Malaysia’s homophobic laws and kissed a male bandmate on stage. The cancellation prompted tighter entry rules for foreign performers.
In February 2025, TV3 apologised after male guests arrived at a red-carpet event in clothing resembling women’s dress.
What changes for future broadcasts?
Nothing in the response yet guarantees an unedited Malaysian broadcast. The EBU has not said whether the participation agreement requires broadcasters to carry the show unedited, or what penalty applies if they remove material.
Voxovation has undertaken to work with TV3 to prevent a repeat, but only a clarified agreement would settle what hosts can expect in future broadcasts.
Source: theguardian.com
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,481 articles



