On viewFilm & Screen

Hunger Games Prequel Sunrise on the Reaping Is a Dreary Slog, Review Says

The 158-minute Hunger Games prequel opens November 20 with a starry cast and heavy CGI. The first major review calls it a dreary slog that mistakes darkness for depth.

‘The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping’ Review: They Shoot Franchises, Don’t They?
‘The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping’ Review: They Shoot Franchises, Don’t They?Dan Stephens / unsplash

Programme

  1. The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping opens in US theaters on November 20.
  2. The prequel runs 158 minutes and is directed by Francis Lawrence, who has directed the franchise since 2013's Catching Fire.
  3. Joseph Zada plays the 16-year-old Haymitch Abernathy in the story of the 50th Hunger Games, the Second Quarter Quell.
  4. The cast includes Glenn Close, Kieran Culkin, Jesse Plemons, Ralph Fiennes, Maya Hawke, Elle Fanning and Lili Taylor.
  5. The film adapts Suzanne Collins' 2025 prequel novel.

"The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping" opens in theaters on Friday, November 20, and one of the first major reviews calls it "a dreary slog." The 158-minute prequel adapts Suzanne Collins' 2025 novel about the teenage years of Haymitch Abernathy, the alcoholic mentor Woody Harrelson played in the original films.

Australian actor Joseph Zada, previously the moody Cal Trask in the recent "East of Eden" series, plays the 16-year-old Haymitch. Francis Lawrence directs again — he has helmed every installment since 2013's "Catching Fire." The reviewer credits the franchise's consistency but warns that newcomers "will find themselves left out in the cold by an overlong, visually soupy, and narratively morose reprisal."

What is the story about?

The film is set during the 50th Hunger Games, known as the Second Quarter Quell. Haymitch enters games rigged from the start, and whose broadcast is edited and deepfaked into pro-Capitol propaganda. The review notes the film "nudges a little bit toward the ethics of state surveillance and how footage can be manipulated or even fabricated for political ends."

His life in District 12 is poor but happy, with girlfriend Lenore (Whitney Peak), his mother and brother (Kara Tointon and Smylie Bradwell), and a best friend who, the film reveals, will become Katniss Everdeen's father. After a reaping — the ceremony where tributes are selected — turns bloody, violence follows Haymitch everywhere, including a tragedy during the horse-drawn Tribute Parade that strikes his childhood friend (Molly McCann).

Who's in the cast?

The ensemble is stacked, though the review argues most of it is wasted:

  • Glenn Close as Drusilla Sickle, her face "grotesquely pulled-tight," channeling Katherine Helmond in "Brazil"
  • Kieran Culkin, "smarmy and mannered," as a Capitol resident
  • Jesse Plemons as a Games camera operator who adds "a shade of moral dimension" but feels "woefully underused"
  • Ralph Fiennes as President Snow, given "but scraps of material"
  • Mckenna Grace as an untrustworthy District 12 tribute; Ben Wang as an endearingly wily ally
  • Maya Hawke, "gravely underused," as the victor of the 49th Games; Kelvin Harrison Jr. as the 34th Games winner; Lili Taylor as a legacy tribute
  • Elle Fanning, "rather amusing," as stylist Effie Trinket, nearly drowned out by outré costumes

Does the prequel work?

The reviewer's verdict is blunt: no. Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie's script sticks faithfully to Collins' novel, but the arena's hidden dangers — poisonous streams, a deadly force field, trippy flora and fauna that "vibe like a dark mirror version of 'Charlie and the Chocolate Factory'" — collapse into "goopy and cacophonous" CGI comparable to a Marvel battle. Most supporting characters exist only to introduce themselves, get labeled good or evil, and be shuffled offscreen.

Zada is charming, the review concedes, but lacks "the gravitational charisma or arc that, say, Jennifer Lawrence brought to the original films." His Haymitch feels like "a cog or a function to get this prequel to line up with the prior films" — which makes the movie "feel a little bit like a cold cash grab rather than a necessary deepening of the series' lore."

The sharpest irony: the film is most interesting only at its tepid coda, when Haymitch returns home and descends into depression and alcoholism. "Not a great sign when your film's tepid coda is also its best moment," the review notes. End-credit cameos "smack of depressing fan service."

What does this change at the box office?

Almost certainly nothing. The review expects this "slice of bankable I.P." to rake in "a hysterical amount of money" regardless of criticism, and possibly launch Zada as a new Hollywood star. These films are "mostly critic-proof" — the November 20 opening will test whether audiences agree that new layers of darkness and trauma count as profundity.

Source: indiewire.com

the-hunger-games, sunrise-on-the-reaping, film-review, suzanne-collins, joseph-zada

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »