On viewVisual Arts

Is Jan van Eyck the Man in the Arnolfini Portrait? A New Catalog Says Maybe

A catalog essay for the National Gallery's November 21 Van Eyck exhibition argues the man in the 1434 Arnolfini Portrait is Jan van Eyck himself, not an Italian merchant.

Who Sat for Jan van Eyck’s Arnolfini Portrait? A New Catalog Essay Suggests It May Have Been the Artist
Who Sat for Jan van Eyck’s Arnolfini Portrait? A New Catalog Essay Suggests It May Have Been the Artistcoyot / pixabay

Programme

  1. The National Gallery's exhibition "Van Eyck: The Portraits" opens November 21 and brings together all nine of Van Eyck's surviving portraits.
  2. Curator Stephan Kemperdick argues the man in the Arnolfini Portrait (1434) is Jan van Eyck himself, based on the inscription's placement beside the figure's head.
  3. Co-curator Nicholas Flory calls the theory "speculative," noting the documented Margaret van Eyck has greyish-blue eyes while the Arnolfini woman has brown.
  4. A 16th-century inventory of Margaret of Austria's collection identifies the painting as "Hernoul le Fin," widely read as "Arnolfini."
  5. The leading traditional candidate, Giovanni di Nicolao Arnolfini, was in his late thirties in 1434; his first wife Costanza Trenta died in 1433.

A new essay in the catalog for "Van Eyck: The Portraits," opening at London's National Gallery on November 21, claims the elegantly dressed man in Jan van Eyck's Arnolfini Portrait (1434) is not an Italian merchant at all — he is Van Eyck himself.

The claim comes from Stephan Kemperdick, a curator at Berlin's Gemäldegalerie, which owns several Van Eycks. As first reported by the Art Newspaper, Kemperdick argues that the painting's famous inscription, "Johannes de Eyck fuit hic. 1434" ("Jan van Eyck was here. 1434"), holds the key.

Why the inscription matters

The words are painted prominently on the wall above the convex mirror in the background, directly next to the male figure's head. Kemperdick reads that placement as a deliberate link: the signature tags the man himself, not just the maker. On that basis, he identifies the sitters as Van Eyck and his wife, Margaret.

That upends the traditional reading. For centuries, scholars have identified the couple as members of the Arnolfini family, Italian merchants based in Bruges. The evidence is a 16th-century inventory of the collection of Margaret of Austria, the painting's owner at the time, which lists the work as "Hernoul le Fin" — widely read as "Arnolfini."

Who else could it be?

The candidates have never been settled. One option is Giovanni di Arrigo Arnolfini, though recent discoveries suggest he wasn't married when the painting was made. The stronger candidate is his cousin, Giovanni di Nicolao Arnolfini, who would have been in his late thirties in 1434.

Giovanni di Nicolao's first wife, Costanza Trenta, died in 1433. According to the National Gallery's website, the woman is probably his second wife, whose identity is unknown. The art historian Margaret Koster and others have proposed instead that the painting is a memorial piece.

The double portrait itself shows a husband and wife, hand in hand in a private room — though not, as was once believed, a marriage ceremony. Every object signals quiet wealth: fur-trimmed clothing, an oriental carpet, and an orange on the windowsill, an expensive luxury at the time. Two additional men, sometimes taken to be Van Eyck and his servant, are reflected entering the room in the convex mirror.

What does this change for other Van Eycks?

If Kemperdick is right, the dominoes fall across Van Eyck's small oeuvre. The National Gallery's Portrait of a Man (1433) — a much older man — is currently tentatively identified as a self-portrait. The Gemäldegalerie's Portrait of a Man in a Red Chaperon (1390–1440/41), which shows the same man as the Arnolfini Portrait at an older age, is still cataloged as Giovanni Arnolfini. Both hang in the London exhibition, which brings together all nine of Van Eyck's surviving portraits. A revised identification of the Berlin picture would ripple straight through the show's labels.

The skeptics push back

Nicholas Flory, the exhibition's co-curator alongside Emma Capron, told the Art Newspaper he finds the theory "interesting" but "speculative." He points to hard visual evidence: another work in the show, on loan from the Musea Brugge, is definitively known to depict Margaret — its inscription says so — and that woman has greyish-blue eyes. The woman in the Arnolfini Portrait has brown eyes.

Till-Holger Borchert, the German art historian and former director of the Musea Brugge, agrees. He considers the 16th-century inventory reference near-conclusive proof that the painting shows an Arnolfini. Still, he concedes the larger problem: given how little is known about Van Eyck's life, "Can you tell me anything about Van Eyck that isn't enigmatic?"

The catalog essay won't settle the argument before the gallery doors open on November 21. But with all nine surviving portraits gathered in one room, visitors will be able to compare the faces — and the eyes — for themselves.

Original: theartnewspaper.com

jan-van-eyck, arnolfini-portrait, national-gallery, art-attribution, early-netherlandish-painting

Also on view

« Previous article