On viewMuseums & Exhibitions

Curator Claims Van Eyck Painted Himself Into the Arnolfini Portrait

A Berlin curator claims the man in Van Eyck's 1434 Arnolfini Portrait is the artist himself and the woman is his wife Margaret—prompting pushback from leading scholars.

Has the pair in Jan van Eyck’s ‘Arnolfini Portrait’ been misidentified?
Has the pair in Jan van Eyck’s ‘Arnolfini Portrait’ been misidentified?11066063 / pixabay

Programme

  1. Stephan Kemperdick argues the couple in the Arnolfini Portrait (1434) are Van Eyck and his wife Margaret, in a catalogue essay for the National Gallery's Van Eyck: The Portraits (21 November-11 April 2027).
  2. The painting has been in the National Gallery since 1842 and bears the inscription 'Jan van Eyck was here 1434'.
  3. The exhibition reunites all nine of Van Eyck's surviving panel portraits, including Margaret's 1439 portrait on loan from Bruges.
  4. Co-curators Flory and Capron call the theory 'interesting' but 'speculative', citing a mismatch in eye colour between the two women.
  5. The Berlin Gemäldegalerie has renamed its companion portrait Portrait of a Man with a Red Chaperon; the London show keeps the Arnolfini label.

A Berlin curator has proposed that the man in Jan van Eyck's Arnolfini Portrait (1434) is Van Eyck himself, and the woman beside him is his wife, Margaret. Stephan Kemperdick, curator of German, Netherlandish and French Paintings before 1600 at the Berlin Gemäldegalerie, makes the claim in a catalogue essay for the National Gallery's exhibition Van Eyck: The Portraits (21 November-11 April 2027), which gathers all nine of the artist's surviving panel portraits.

The painting has hung in London's National Gallery since 1842. Its prominent Latin inscription reads "Jan van Eyck was here 1434", and beyond that, Kemperdick notes, almost everything about it has been contested—except the man's surname. Arnolfini, a wealthy merchant family from Lucca, was active in 15th-century Bruges, where Van Eyck ran his studio.

What's the case for the new identification?

Kemperdick points to the inscription itself, which is unusually large and conspicuously places the artist's name next to the male figure's head. He reads that as a direct link between Van Eyck and the man. He also reinterprets a 16th-century inventory reference to "hernoul le fin"—long read as the French form of the Italian surname Arnolfini. Citing early-modern descriptions of the work not as a portrait but as a lewd genre painting, Kemperdick argues "hernoul le fin" was a mocking moniker pinned on later, misidentifying the man as "a deceived cheat". A bedstead statue of St Margaret near the woman's head, he suggests, identifies her as Van Eyck's wife—the sitter in his 1439 portrait, on loan to the show from Bruges.

The idea isn't entirely new. In the late 1840s, the National Gallery's future first director Charles Eastlake argued the inscription could mean "Jan van Eyck was this [one]", making the picture a dual portrait of the artist and his wife. In the early 1860s, the British art historian W. H. James Weale linked "hernoul le fin" to the Arnolfini family, and that identification stuck—though scholars still fight over which Arnolfini is depicted.

What do other scholars say?

The show's co-curators, Nicholas Flory and Emma Capron, call Kemperdick's theory "interesting" but "speculative". They note the woman in the Bruges portrait, known to be Margaret from its inscription, has greyish-blue eyes; the woman in the Arnolfini Portrait has brown eyes.

Till-Holger Borchert, director of the Suermondt-Ludwig-Museum in Aachen and former director of Musea Brugge, is also unconvinced. "I'm not entirely sure I can concur," he says. He sees the inventory reference—linked to the painting's then-owner Margaret of Austria, governor of the Habsburg Netherlands—as near iron-clad. Ghent University's Maximiliaan Martens "doesn't see any reason to doubt" the Arnolfini reading either.

What does this change for the National Gallery?

The stakes are real. The gallery's 1433 Van Eyck portrait of an older man is tentatively labelled a self-portrait—but that can't stand if Kemperdick is right. Meanwhile, the two museums are split on labels. The London show will keep the Arnolfini reference for the Berlin portrait of the same man (around 1435-38); the Gemäldegalerie has renamed it Portrait of a Man with a Red Chaperon.

The old questions haven't gone away either. Martens, after 30 years of thinking about the couple, still can't decide between Giovanni di Arrigo Arnolfini (apparently unmarried in 1434) and his cousin Giovanni di Nicolao (whose wife had died by then). Scholars also disagree on whether the heavy-bellied woman is pregnant and whether the room is real or imagined.

Even Van Eyck's own birth date and place remain speculation. "Can you tell me anything about Van Eyck that isn't enigmatic?" Borchert asks. The debate will run well past the show's April close.

Source: theartnewspaper.com

jan-van-eyck, arnolfini-portrait, national-gallery, van-eyck-the-portraits, art-attribution

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »