Lempertz to Auction Two Gothic Panels Claimed as Nazi-Looted
Lempertz will offer two Johann Koerbecke panels, each estimated at €300,000, despite the Max Stern Foundation's claim they were Nazi-looted and a second restitution claim by Funke heirs.

Programme
- Lempertz plans to sell two Koerbecke panels on Saturday despite a Stern Foundation claim they were 'stolen'.
- Both works carry high estimates of about €300,000 ($329,000) each, the sale's top lots.
- Both paintings appear on the German Lost Art Database (registered 2018) and in the Interpol Database of Stolen Art since 2021.
- Bavarian museums and Cologne's Kolumba Art Museum restituted the two works to Funke heirs in 2025.
- The German Advisory Commission stated in 2019 that no 'proper, customary business transactions' by Jewish dealers can be assumed after August 1933.
Cologne auction house Lempertz said it will sell two Gothic panels by Johann Koerbecke on Saturday, despite the heirs of German Jewish dealer Max Stern calling the works "stolen." Each carries a high estimate of around 300,000 euros, about $329,000, making them the most expensive lots in the Old Masters sale.
The two paintings — The Annunciation and The Vision of Saint Bernard — likely come from the Marienfeld high altarpiece, completed in 1457. "For art historical reasons," the Lempertz lot entries read, "the two important panels (Lots 1005 and 1006) will first be offered individually and then together."
Who is claiming the paintings?
Stern held the paintings at his Düsseldorf gallery between 1936 and 1937, the year the Nazis shut it down. According to Lempertz's provenance, both works then passed to Düsseldorf's Galerie Hans Bammann, which appears to have sold them.
On Monday, the Dr. Max and Iris Stern Foundation called on Lempertz to halt the sale. In its release, the foundation said no sale should occur "until two distinct ownership claims of different victims are justly resolved according to the Washington Principles on Nazi-Confiscated Art" — the 1998 international framework for handling art looted during the Nazi era.
The foundation registered its claim on the German Lost Art Database in 2018, where both works are reported as "Nazi-confiscated property." Both paintings also appear in several databases of missing artworks, including the Interpol Database of Stolen Art since 2021.
Why are there two competing claims?
Before Stern owned the Koerbecke panels, they belonged to Ellen Funke. The Nazis classified her as a Mischling — "mongrel" — because of Jewish ancestry through her mother. She sold her collection in 1936 to fund her emigration from Germany.
That history complicates matters considerably:
- In 2025, Bavaria's state museums (the Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen) restituted The Vision of Saint Bernard to Funke's heirs. Funke's heirs are the listed sellers of that work at Lempertz.
- The same year, the Kolumba Art Museum of the Archdiocese of Cologne restituted The Annunciation, which had entered the museum as a 1996 donation. Funke's heirs are listed as its sellers too.
- The Bavarian museums noted that both images were once painted on either side of a single panel, and that Stern had them taken apart in hopes of selling both.
The Stern Foundation's release does not name Funke. It states, however, that the foundation "maintains that the rights and histories of both Jewish victims must be taken into account, and neither claim should be privileged at the expense of the other."
A foundation spokesperson told ARTnews that "the museums restituted the paintings to Ellen Funke's heirs in accordance with the priority principle set forth in the guidelines established in Germany to apply the Washington Principles," adding that the restitution "did not result in a 'just and fair solution' in accordance with the Washington Principles."
What does Lempertz say?
In a statement to ARTnews, Lempertz said it would not cancel the sale of works by Koerbecke, widely considered one of the great painters of the German Gothic era.
"We adhere to current restitution practices and follow the recommendations of the Federal Government," a representative said. The representative claimed Stern "had the panels sawn in two" and sold one for "double the price." The representative added: "These magnificent paintings were not taken away from Max Stern," and, "Max Stern received compensation after the war; the heirs of the Funke family did not."
The Stern Foundation rejected both arguments. Its spokesperson said the "view that the paintings were not 'seized' from Max Stern has long been refuted," citing a 2019 statement from the now-defunct German Advisory Commission (the country's former mediation body for restitution disputes). That statement held that persecution of Jewish art dealers began at latest by August 1933, "so that from that point on at the latest, it can in no way be assumed that 'proper, customary business transactions' took place." The spokesperson called the claim that Stern was compensated "incorrect" and said it has "no legal basis."
Lempertz did not dispute the paintings' listings on the Art Loss Register (a private database of stolen art), though its representative noted the listings contain details of the works' respective restitutions.
The Stern Foundation has demanded the return of multiple artworks over the past decade, with some success. In 2017, the FBI returned a painting by Jan Franse Verzijl to Stern's heirs after it appeared at a US art fair two years earlier.
Saturday's sale will now test whether the market sides with the auction house's reading of restitution practice — or with two sets of heirs, each tracing loss to 1936.
Original: lempertz.com
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
News editor covering companies, deals and strategy in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,510 articles



