On viewArt Market

Sotheby's Settles Fischer Heirs' Claim, Clearing $180M Van Gogh Sale

Sotheby's and the Blaquier-Arrieta family settled with the Fischer heirs over the $180M van Gogh, resolving the ownership claim days before Wednesday's auction.

Sotheby’s, Blaquier-Arrieta Family Reach Deal With Fischer Heirs, Clearing Way for $180 M. Van Gogh Sale
Sotheby’s, Blaquier-Arrieta Family Reach Deal With Fischer Heirs, Clearing Way for $180 M. Van Gogh Salestux / pixabay

Programme

  1. Vincent van Gogh's 'Châtaigniers en fleurs' (1890) carries a $180 million estimate and sells Wednesday night at Sotheby's.
  2. The Blaquier-Arrieta family has owned the painting since 1975; the sale leads a $450 million collection auction.
  3. Sotheby's says Cassirer archives show the 1936 Amsterdam sale fetched 68,000 Swiss francs, about $22,000.
  4. Gisela Bermann Fischer, who died in 2014, had pursued Nazi-era restitution claims since before 2007.
  5. The settlement's terms were not disclosed and does not establish whether the 1936 sale was made under duress.

Sotheby's has settled with the heirs of Jewish publisher Hedwig and Samuel Fischer, clearing the way for Vincent van Gogh's Châtaigniers en fleurs (1890) to sell on Wednesday night with an estimate of $180 million.

The auction house said Tuesday that the Blaquier-Arrieta family, which has owned the painting since 1975, reached the agreement with all legal descendants of the Fischers. Sotheby's confirmed to ARTnews that the settlement resolves the ownership claims and that the buyer will receive clear title. The terms were not disclosed.

What sparked the dispute?

The public brawl erupted last Thursday in the pages of the New York Times, just six days before the painting was due to lead Sotheby's $450 million sale of the Blaquier-Arrieta collection.

The Fischer heirs argued their family had been forced to sell the painting in Amsterdam in 1936 because of financial pressures brought on by Nazi persecution. Their Berlin lawyer, Gunnar Schnabel, demanded Sotheby's withdraw the work unless it could prove the transaction was voluntary.

Sotheby's disputed that account. Citing records from the archives of art dealer Paul Cassirer, the auction house said the painting sold in June 1936 for 68,000 Swiss francs — roughly $22,000 at the time. Sotheby's maintained this was a fair price for a van Gogh, and noted the picture had already been in Amsterdam for nearly three years before the sale.

Was the timing a pressure tactic?

Several art-market professionals who spoke to ARTnews anonymously saw the claim that way. It arrived when Sotheby's had little time to respond and much to lose. The auction house had guaranteed the work for an undisclosed sum and had promoted it for months as the star of one of the season's biggest sales.

Judd Grossman, a New York art lawyer not involved in the dispute, warned that recent changes to the HEAR Act, which governs Nazi-era restitution claims, could encourage more of what he called "gamesmanship by claimants waiting to the very last minute to come forward before seeking their slice of the pie." In a separate ongoing lawsuit, lawyers for the Republic of Austria, the Albertina Museum and the Leopold Museum Foundation have labeled the updated HEAR Act unconstitutional.

What does the settlement actually settle?

Not the underlying question. Whether the Fischer heirs received financial compensation is unclear, and the deal does not establish whether the 1936 sale happened under duress. Sotheby's said the agreement recognized both the painting's complicated history and the persecution the Fischer family suffered under the Nazis.

The Fischer heirs thanked Sotheby's and the Blaquier-Arrieta family for what they called a "trusting and fair negotiation" that acknowledged their family's suffering and honored Gisela Bermann Fischer's long pursuit of restitution. Bermann Fischer, who died in 2014, had previously sought restitution for Nazi-era losses; in 2007 she declined to oppose the sale of a Paul Cezanne work that passed through the same Amsterdam dealer, while expressly reserving the right to challenge other sales.

The Blaquier-Arrieta family responded in kind, saying it looked forward to "an extraordinary result and to passing along this masterpiece to a new generation of collectors." Wednesday's sale will now test whether that confidence translates into a price near the $180 million mark — and whether last-minute HEAR Act claims become a recurring feature of marquee auctions.

Original: nytimes.com

vincent-van-gogh, sotheby-s, chataigniers-en-fleurs, provenance-disputes, nazi-era-restitution

Also on view

« Previous article