On viewArt Market

Heirs Demand Sotheby’s Pull $180M Van Gogh From Sale

Heirs of publisher Samuel Fischer want Sotheby's to pull the $180M Van Gogh sold by the family in 1936 Amsterdam; also: the Vision Theatre's $40M reopening.

Jewish Heirs Challenge Sotheby’s $180M Van Gogh
Jewish Heirs Challenge Sotheby’s $180M Van GoghSchwarzenarzisse / pixabay

Programme

  1. Heirs of Samuel Fischer want Sotheby's to withdraw the $180 million Van Gogh 'Blossoming Chestnut Trees' from Wednesday's sale.
  2. The family sold the painting in 1936 in Amsterdam, leaving no postwar legal basis for restitution.
  3. About 50 works from a $300 million collection pledged to Seattle University are being sold to repay a bank loan.
  4. The Vision Theatre, a 1931 Art Deco movie palace in Leimert Park, reopens after a 20-year, $40 million renovation.
  5. Guatemala welcomed home Miguel Ángel Asturias's ashes in a 70-pound jade urn with a Mayan ceremony.

Heirs of the German Jewish publisher Samuel Fischer want Sotheby's to withdraw Blossoming Chestnut Trees, the $180 million top lot of Wednesday's sale. The family sold the Van Gogh in 1936, three months after fleeing Berlin, according to The New York Times.

The catch is geography. The sale took place in Amsterdam, so after the war the family had no legal basis to reclaim the painting under restitution rules (laws governing recovery of art sold under Nazi-era duress, which vary by country of sale). A forced sale in Germany could be unwound; a forced sale in the Netherlands, apparently, could not. The heirs are asking the auction house to pull the canvas on moral rather than legal grounds.

Sotheby's has not said publicly whether it will. A $180 million lot concentrates the mind.

What else is on the block?

The same sale includes about 50 works from a collection once valued at $300 million and billed, at the time, as the largest art gift ever made to a U.S. university. Seattle University, the Seattle Times reports, received a pledge — not the paintings. The sale now serves to pay off a bank loan the paintings secured. The university got the announcement; the bank got the collateral.

Can a movie palace come back from the dead?

The Vision Theatre, a 1931 Art Deco movie palace in Los Angeles's Leimert Park, reopens this weekend after a 20-year, $40 million city renovation. Tina Knowles's arts nonprofit will run the programming, the Los Angeles Times reports.

The building has history. Marla Gibbs of The Jeffersons bought the theatre in 1990 and lost it to foreclosure. The city spent two decades and $40 million undoing decades of neglect; it is roughly the cost of a fifth of the Van Gogh, which puts municipal priorities in an odd light.

Why does one cracked voice count as art?

Writer Lauren Elkin's new book, Vocal Break, asks why Edith Piaf's cracked voice is heard as art while Celine Dion's is heard as selling records. Elkin discussed the question with NPR. The book sits in the growing literature on how audiences grade women's voices — authenticity for some, commerce for others — and the grading rarely favors the living.

What happened to Guatemala's exiled Nobel laureate?

Guatemala stripped its Nobel-winning novelist Miguel Ángel Asturias of citizenship after the 1954 coup. He died in exile. This week his ashes came home in a 70-pound jade urn, the Seattle Times reports, honored with a Mayan ceremony. A state that revoked his passport eventually spent on his homecoming a vessel of the country's most storied stone. That is a form of apology, delivered in mineral form.

The week's through-line is provenance: who owned the Van Gogh, who actually held the Seattle collection, who kept the Vision Theatre alive. The Fischer heirs' claim will test whether auction houses price morality when the law declines to.

Source: artsjournal.com

vincent-van-gogh, sotheby-s, art-restitution, art-auctions, provenance

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »