On viewArts & Culture

Macaulay's London Week: Reich at Last, and a Mezzo for the Ages

Macaulay hears Steve Reich live for the first time at 90, hails Beth Taylor's finest Covent Garden Mahler in 51 years, and questions the Royal Ballet's charm.

Alastair Macaulay: I love Steve Reich but never heard him live
Alastair Macaulay: I love Steve Reich but never heard him liveKamots / pixabay

Programme

  1. Steve Reich turned 90 in October 2026; Macaulay attended his first live Reich concert on 12 November at the Barbican, conducted by Susanna Mälkki.
  2. Beth Taylor's singing in Song of the Earth was called the finest Covent Garden interpretation of that Mahler music in 51 years.
  3. The Royal Ballet's Visionaries programme runs at Covent Garden until 28 November 2026.
  4. Tom Littler will leave the Orange Tree Theatre in June 2027 to lead the Cambridge Arts Theatre.
  5. The Jerusalem Quartet, founded in 1996, played Mozart, Bartók and Ravel at Wigmore Hall on 7 November.

Steve Reich turned ninety in October 2026, and Alastair Macaulay heard his music live for the first time only now. The critic in residence, writing for Arts & Voices, attended five Reich works at the Barbican on Thursday 12 November, conducted by Susanna Mälkki with the London Symphony Orchestra. He called the earliest piece on the programme, Music for Pieces of Wood (1973), the one that "sticks most marvellously and entertainingly in my head", and confessed he has nicknamed it Woodpeckers at a Gathering. The concert ran from that 1973 delight to Music for Ensemble and Orchestra (2018), "without a moment of tepidity or tedium". Reich, Macaulay wrote, "has a toughness of mind that makes all his music rewarding".

The week began on Saturday 7 November at Wigmore Hall, where the Jerusalem Quartet, founded in 1996, played Mozart's Hunt Quartet K458 (1784), Bartók's Sixth Quartet (1939) and Ravel's Quartet (1903). Macaulay judged it "one of the greatest concerts of the year", praising "the attack, wit, and vividness of their playing". He argued Mozart, in his Haydn quartets, was challenging form as radically as Bartók and Ravel later would.

What did Adès and Saariaho deliver at the Barbican?

On Sunday 8 November Thomas Adès conducted the LSO and London Symphony Chorus in a programme pairing him with Sibelius, plus Kaija Saariaho's choral cantata Oltra Mar (1999), subtitled Seven preludes for the new millennium. Macaulay found Oltra Mar written "in the same spirit and colours" as the opera he adores, L'Amour de loin (2000), unlike Innocence (2021), "on which I could find no handle at all". Adès's own America – a prophecy, in its 2024 revision, drew a sharper verdict: the score shows his "virtual indifference to direct verbal communication". Soprano Anna Dennis sang in a "purer-than-thou style" that added "one more level of detachment". Sibelius's The Oceanides and single-movement Seventh Symphony completed a bill Macaulay read as environmentalist in sympathy, though he found Adès's conducting "unnecessarily demonstrative".

Is the Royal Ballet drowning Robbins in charm?

The Royal Ballet's Visionaries programme, in repertory at Covent Garden until 28 November, pairs Robbins's Dances at a Gathering (1969) with MacMillan's Song of the Earth. Macaulay rejected the title's premise, noting that Ashton, Balanchine, Fokine and Nijinska would furnish rival Visionaries programmes. Of the 2026 cast — Marcelino Sambé, Yasmine Naghdi, Reece Clarke, Mayara Magri among others — he admired Sambé, Joseph Sissens and Magri, whose detail was "less overlaid with self-conscious manners". Naghdi he found "the most tiresomely adorable", recalling Marcia B. Siegel's jibe that the original production was Dances at a Garden Party.

MacMillan's Song of the Earth fared worse: its "heavy expressionism", clunky word-settings and staccato answers to Mahler's legato lines have worn badly since 1975. The revival's "great event", Macaulay wrote, is Beth Taylor's singing of the second, fourth and sixth songs — "the finest interpretation of the music I have heard at Covent Garden in fifty-one years". Marianela Nuñez dances the lead "with a refreshingly complete lack of sentimentality".

Churchill, Cranford and a departure that stings

At the National Theatre on 10 November, Dominic Cooke's production of Caryl Churchill's Cloud 9 (1979) drew rapture at press night. Sam Troughton, as Clive and the child Cathy, is "a constantly exciting source of energy"; the whole cast is excellent.

At Richmond's Orange Tree Theatre on 13 November, a new Cranford, adapted by Lin Coghlan and Shaun McKenna and directed by Josh Roche, captured Elizabeth Gaskell's novel better than the 2007 television series. Tamsin Greig's understated Miss Matty is "exemplary". The news that artistic director Tom Littler leaves in June 2027 for the Cambridge Arts Theatre, Macaulay wrote, "leaves a gap that will be hard to fill".

Source: Slipped Disc

steve-reich, london-arts, london-symphony-orchestra, royal-ballet, caryl-churchill

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »