On viewFilm & Screen

Sharon Horgan's 'Youth' Failed Middle-Aged Women, Critic Argues

Glynnis MacNicol, writing in the New York Times, calls Sharon Horgan's HBO series "Youth" a failure to middle-aged women — praising only "The Diplomat" as close to real life.

How Bad Is TV At Depicting Middle-Aged Women?
How Bad Is TV At Depicting Middle-Aged Women?12019 / pixabay

Programme

  1. Sharon Horgan's HBO series "Youth" concluded its eight-episode run in early December.
  2. In 2023, 45 percent of U.S. mothers were breadwinners; 30 percent of women aged 50-64 were single.
  3. Next year at least 18 women will serve as state governors and at least 23 in the U.S. Senate.
  4. Late-1980s network TV drew over 10 million viewers a night with shows like "Murphy Brown" and "The Golden Girls."

Sharon Horgan's HBO series "Youth" ended its eight-episode run this month, and New York Times contributing Opinion writer Glynnis MacNicol watched it "with equal parts exasperation and rage."

Her verdict is blunt: television remains terrible at portraying middle-aged women, and "Youth" is the latest evidence. The show centers on Alex, a 50-something divorced literary agent re-entering dating after sending her son off to college, while caring for aging parents. MacNicol calls that "sandwich generation" (squeezed between caring for children and parents) premise "rich stuff." She thinks Horgan squandered it.

What went wrong with 'Youth'?

Horgan, 56, is the creator of "Catastrophe" and "Bad Sisters," and MacNicol credits her with repeatedly bringing "complicated, intelligent, fully realized, grown-up women to the screen." With "Youth," she argues, Horgan delivers instead an immature, insecure heroine — inept at work, anxious about male approval, drunkenly sleeping with a lecherous former client in one episode and passing out in a cab in another.

MacNicol's comparison: it's "as though someone has stuck Bridget Jones in the body of a 50-year-old and said, here, this is adulthood." A coda, she writes, to the "Sex and the City" episode where a hung-over Carrie lands on New York magazine under the headline "Single and Fabulous?"

How rare is the onscreen reality?

The essay anchors its argument in hard numbers. In 2023, 45 percent of American mothers were breadwinners, and 30 percent of U.S. women aged 50 to 64 reported being single. Yet screens offer, in MacNicol's reading, older actresses behaving like 20-somethings — Nicole Kidman's timid BDSM-entrance in "Babygirl," the "silly" reboot "And Just Like That." Her complaint about "Babygirl" is precise: "It's the timidity, not the relationship, that I found so frustrating." There is, she writes, "no competence to back up the chaos. No learned wisdom."

She notes the problem isn't new — Kerry Washington's Olivia Pope in "Scandal" and Sandra Oh's Eve in "Killing Eve" pioneered messy women, a necessary pushback after decades of the tolerant sitcom wife. But now women "seem to require extreme backdrops to get main-character screen time": Kathy Bates in "Matlock," Quincy Tyler Bernstine's FBI agent in Hulu's "Furious," Ryan Murphy's "Feud: Capote vs. The Swans" and "All's Fair."

What does good look like?

The exception, for MacNicol, is "The Diplomat" on FX and Hulu. Keri Russell's ambassador Kate Wyler — joined this season by Jodie Whittaker's British prime minister and Allison Janney's "deliciously conniving" American president — is "powerful and tired and full of contradictions," making it "the closest approximation to real life that we have." Former ambassador Samantha Power recently told a Harvard Kennedy School panel with Russell and creator Debora Cahn that Wyler's indifference to clothes and hair was close to reality.

MacNicol also invokes television history: "Designing Women" (CBS, 1986-93), "Murphy Brown" — whose pregnancy plot enraged Vice President Dan Quayle — and "The Golden Girls" (NBC, 1985-92) filled late-1980s prime time, when networks averaged well over 10 million viewers a night, with successful older women and men as mere B roll.

She pitches better story lines: women screened out of the job market by AI résumé filters, pressure to erase evidence of age, or simply — "gasp!" — a woman having fun.

The political backdrop sharpens the point. Next year at least 18 women will serve as governors, including the first Black woman, and at least 23 women in the Senate, including the first Native American woman in that body. "Now that's a show I'd tune in to watch," MacNicol writes — a challenge Hollywood has so far declined to meet.

Source: artsjournal.com

sharon-horgan, youth, television-criticism, middle-aged-women, representation

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »