On viewMusic

Steven Osborne's 'OK By Me' Earns Five Stars for Wild-Range Programming

Norman Lebrecht awards five stars to Steven Osborne's Hyperion album 'OK By Me', spanning Bach, Rachmaninoff, Joni Mitchell and a honky-tonk Liebestod, and calls for a weekly radio show.

A five-star pianist for lovers of singles over 30
A five-star pianist for lovers of singles over 30kailingpiano / pixabay

Programme

  1. Steven Osborne's album 'OK By Me' was released on the Hyperion label and rated five stars
  2. The programme spans Bach, Grieg, Rachmaninoff, Davies, Tippett, Jarrett, Monk, Mitchell and Poulenc
  3. Reviewer Norman Lebrecht retracts his earlier criticism of celebrity compilation albums
  4. Lebrecht calls for Osborne to receive a weekly one-hour Sunday radio slot

Steven Osborne's new album OK By Me has received a five-star rating from Norman Lebrecht's Album of the Week column. The Scottish pianist released the recording on the Hyperion label.

Lebrecht, writing as NL, opened his review with a confession. A month earlier, he had criticised lapses of taste in compilation albums by celebrated pianists. "I knew it would not be long before I'd have to eat my words," he wrote.

Who is Steven Osborne?

Osborne is, in Lebrecht's phrase, "celebrated chiefly among the kind of cognoscenti who would not touch a single malt under 30 years old" — a connoisseur's connoisseur. The reviewer calls him "a formidable mind whose approach to music is altogether original and unexpected."

The title track is a short piece of Osborne's own. Lebrecht praises its "compelling quietude and self-certainty," and evokes "hints of wet Edinburgh alleys on a winter's morning and the distant moan of an Atlantic wind as the amber liquor swirls in cut glass."

What is on the album?

The programme ranges across centuries and genres with no warning. Lebrecht lists the sequence:

  • The title track, Osborne's own composition
  • Works by Bach, Grieg and Rachmaninoff
  • Peter Maxwell Davies's Farewell to Stromness
  • Isoldina, described by Lebrecht as the Tristan Liebestod played on a honky-tonk piano — "completely off the wall"
  • Osborne's own improvisation on the closing chord of Michael Tippett's opera The Ice Break
  • Music by Keith Jarrett, Meredith Monk and Joni Mitchell
  • Three fragments of Poulenc

The Tippett connection carries a barbed aside. Lebrecht notes that The Ice Break holds "the lowest ratings of anything ever shown on British television." Osborne's improvisation grows out of that opera's final chord — out of nowhere, in the reviewer's words.

What does the reviewer want next?

Lebrecht closes with a direct appeal to broadcasters. "Can someone please give this man an hour every Sunday on classical radio?" he asks. His argument: "He will greatly increase the sum of human happiness, not to mention the ratings."

The review ends on a final superlative for the repertoire's core: Osborne's Schumann is "off-the-scale rapturous."

For Lebrecht, who built his column's authority on scepticism toward celebrity compilations, the verdict reverses his own prior complaint. The takeaway: a single-disc programme running from Bach to Joni Mitchell can earn five stars when the pianist's mind, not the marketing department, dictates the running order.

Source: Slipped Disc

steven-osborne, ok-by-me, classical-piano, album-review, norman-lebrecht

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »