Two Mahler Competition Finalists Reunite Over Tosca in New York
Oksana Lyniv and Gustavo Dudamel, finalists at the 2004 Mahler Conducting Competition, reunited in New York while both conduct Tosca — she at the Met, he at Carnegie Hall.

Programme
- Oksana Lyniv and Gustavo Dudamel met again for the first time in 22 years.
- Both were finalists at the inaugural Gustav Mahler Conducting Competition in Bamberg in 2004.
- Dudamel placed first in 2004; Lyniv placed third; Ivo Venkov of Bulgaria placed second.
- Lyniv is conducting a revival of Tosca at The Metropolitan Opera.
- Dudamel conducted a concert Tosca at Carnegie Hall in his first season leading the New York Philharmonic.
Twenty-two years after they competed against each other in Bamberg, Oksana Lyniv and Gustavo Dudamel are both conducting Tosca in New York at the same time. Lyniv broke the news herself, in a social media post documenting an unexpected reunion.
"It was impossible to hold back our emotions — today marked our first reunion in 22 years, ever since we became finalists at the inaugural Gustav Mahler Conducting Competition by the Bamberger Symphoniker in 2004!" the Ukrainian conductor wrote.
The staging of the coincidence is almost too neat. One Puccini opera, two conductors who first met as competition finalists, one city.
Who is doing what in New York?
Lyniv is conducting the revival of Tosca at The Metropolitan Opera. Dudamel, meanwhile, has just led a concert performance of the same opera at Carnegie Hall. That performance falls within what Lyniv described as his "inaugural saison" as Music & Artistic Director of the New York Philharmonic.
She did not stint on praise for her former rival. Dudamel's Carnegie Hall Tosca was, in her words, "amazing." The conductor kept the quote simple. So did the verdict.
"It's amazing how unexpected the paths of life can be, and what a joy it is to finally see each other again!" Lyniv wrote.
What happened in Bamberg in 2004?
The record from the inaugural Gustav Mahler Conducting Competition, run by the Bamberger Symphoniker (the Bavarian orchestra based in Bamberg, Germany), is brief but pointed. Dudamel came first. Lyniv came third. Between them, in second place, stood the Bulgarian conductor Ivo Venkov.
The 2004 result reads, in hindsight, like a preview of two careers that would land both finalists on major New York podiums two decades apart. Dudamel took the top prize and rose swiftly. Lyniv, finishing two places behind him, took the longer road to the Met.
The competition, named after Gustav Mahler, has clearly functioned as a career-launcher for at least its first-year alumni. One winner now runs the New York Philharmonic. One third-place finisher now conducts revivals at the Metropolitan Opera. The second-place finisher's name is on the record, and the record is where it stays for now.
Why does the reunion matter?
The story is a reminder that conducting's biggest prizes are rarely the whole tale. A jury ranked Venkov above Lyniv in 2004. In November 2026, it is Lyniv who is on the Met podium and posting photographs of her reunion with the winner — first as they are now, then as they were, two young finalists at the start.
Both conductors now share not just a competition history but a repertoire, a city and a month. Whether the two Toscas invite comparison is a question for New York audiences. Lyniv, for her part, has already delivered her review of Dudamel's. It ran to one word.
Source: Slipped Disc
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
News editor covering companies, deals and strategy in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,456 articles



