On viewArt Market

Van Gogh's Chestnut Trees in Blossom Fetches Record $190.4m

Sotheby's sells Van Gogh's 1890 Chataigniers en fleurs for a record $190.4m, hours after the seller settled with heirs of publisher Samuel Fischer over the family's 1936 Nazi-era sale.

Vincent van Gogh painting auctioned for record $190.4m after dispute over Nazi era sale
Vincent van Gogh painting auctioned for record $190.4m after dispute over Nazi era saleart_muse / pixabay

Programme

  1. Van Gogh's Chataigniers en fleurs (1890) sold for $190.4m at Sotheby's on Wednesday, a new auction record for the artist.
  2. The price beat the previous Van Gogh record of $117.2m for Orchard with Cypresses, set at Christie's in November 2022.
  3. The New York Times reported William Acquavella of Acquavella Galleries bought the painting.
  4. The seller, the Blaquier-Arrieta family (owners since 1975), reached a settlement with heirs of Samuel Fischer, who sold the work in 1936 under Nazi-era financial pressure.
  5. The NYT also reported Van Gogh's 1888 Le Zouave sold privately for 'around $190m' through Christie's within the past year.

By Daniel Okafor

A Van Gogh painted in his last spring just became the most expensive Van Gogh ever sold at auction. Sotheby's hammered down Chataigniers en fleurs (Chestnut Trees in Blossom) for $190.4m (£144.9m, A$285m) on Wednesday.

The 1890 canvas, painted in Auvers-sur-Oise, France, also ranks as the priciest work auctioned this season. The New York Times reported that William Acquavella, head of Acquavella Galleries, placed the winning bid.

What record did it break?

The previous auction record for a Van Gogh stood at $117.2m. That was Orchard with Cypresses, an 1888 work sold at Christie's in New York in November 2022. The new price beats it by more than $70m.

There is a wrinkle. The Times reported on Wednesday that another 1888 Van Gogh, Le Zouave, changed hands for "around $190m" in a private transaction through Christie's less than a year ago. Private deals don't set auction records. They do, however, set expectations.

Why did Nazi-era claims hang over the sale?

The painting's provenance did the heavy lifting in this story. Samuel Fischer, the influential German publisher, acquired the work in Paris in 1909. His family sold it in 1936.

The heirs argued the family parted with the painting only because of financial losses suffered under the Nazis. Their Berlin-based lawyer, Gunnar Schnabel, had demanded that Sotheby's prove the painting fetched its market value in 1936, and that the family would have sold it regardless of the political context. That's restitution logic in a sentence: coercion vitiates consent.

The Blaquier-Arrieta family, which bought the painting in 1975 and held it for more than half a century per Sotheby's, faced the claims head-on. On Tuesday, the auction house announced that "an agreement has been reached between the Blaquier-Arrieta family and all of the legal descendants of Hedwig and Samuel Fischer regarding the sale of Vincent van Gogh's Chataigniers en fleurs."

What was said after the hammer fell?

Schnabel told the New York Times in a statement that "the family hopes that the considerable public interest in this case, and its fast and fair and just resolution, may offer some encouragement to other families who have faced persecution during the Nazi era." The auction room itself, he added, had "no Champagne atmosphere." A $190.4m sale with a sober aftertaste — that's a first for the season.

Sotheby's relayed the Fischer heirs' own words: they were "grateful for the trusting and fair negotiation and collaboration with Sotheby's and the Blaquier-Arrieta family, which make it possible to acknowledge the suffering of the Fischer family during the Nazi era and honor Gisela Berman Fischer's history of seeking justice for her family."

What does the settlement signal?

Restitution disputes usually drag. This one resolved in time for the lot to cross the block, and the resolution preceded a record price by roughly 24 hours. Other claimant families now have a precedent in which a negotiated settlement cleared the way for a nine-figure sale, and the market absorbed a Nazi-era provenance question without flinching.

Source: theguardian.com

vincent-van-gogh, sotheby-s, auction-records, art-provenance, nazi-era-restitution

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »