Sotheby's Faces Heirs' Claim Over $180 Million van Gogh Days Before Sale
A $180 million van Gogh headed to Wednesday's auction is at the center of a Nazi-era restitution claim. Heirs of publisher Samuel Fischer say the 1936 sale was made under duress.

Programme
- A van Gogh valued at about $180 million is due at Sotheby's on Wednesday amid a Nazi-era restitution claim.
- Heirs of publisher Samuel Fischer say the 1890 painting was sold under duress in 1936; lawyers meet Monday in Manhattan.
- This month a Paris court ordered Sotheby's to return a Pissarro to heirs of banker Salomon Flavian, seized in 1941.
- Congress this year extended the Holocaust Expropriated Art Recovery Act, giving heirs more time to file claims.
- Sotheby's top provenance expert Lucian Simmons left in 2024 after nearly 30 years for the Met Museum.
A van Gogh landscape valued at around $180 million goes to auction at Sotheby's on Wednesday — but lawyers for the auction house and Jewish heirs claiming the painting will meet in Manhattan on Monday to discuss a potential settlement first.
The work at stake is "Châtaigniers en Fleurs (Blossoming Chestnut Trees)," an 1890 landscape by Vincent van Gogh. Earlier on Friday, hours before Sotheby's chief executive Charles Stewart hosted billionaires including Linda Macklowe, Hubert Neumann and Mitchell Morgan at a dinner of beef and mashed potatoes, heirs of a previous Jewish owner formally asked the house to withdraw the lot. They assert the painting was sold under duress in 1936 because of Nazi-era persecution.
Stewart, according to the dinner guests' account of the evening, gave a rousing speech about more than $1 billion worth of artworks Sotheby's plans to sell this week. He did not mention the dispute over the week's marquee lot.
What does the dispute change for the sale?
Plenty, by the account of industry experts. Questions about the van Gogh's provenance (the documented chain of ownership for an artwork) were already circulating ahead of the sale. A public dispute could scare off buyers who would want to know how Sotheby's let a painting with a troubled history reach the salesroom at all.
"It's a nightmare for Sotheby's. It's a nightmare for the owners. It's a nightmare for the buyers," said Philip Hoffman, an art adviser and former auction-world executive.
Hoffman said even a settlement might not calm frustrated collectors, because additional heirs could emerge with claims and complicate any agreement — before or after the sale. "We as art advisers stop our clients' going into anything troublesome, when we could go find something else for $150 million with no trouble at all," he said.
Luke Nikas, a lawyer representing Sotheby's, said Sunday that the company "takes provenance and restitution matters extremely seriously and has undertaken extensive research into the ownership history."
Whose painting was it?
The van Gogh belonged to the family of Samuel Fischer, a Jewish-born German publisher. Gunnar Schnabel, a lawyer for one group of heirs, said the family deposited the painting with an Amsterdam gallery in the early 1930s, and that its 1936 sale came under duress.
The painting resurfaced this year as part of the Blaquier-Arrieta collection, a trove amassed by an Argentine family that made its fortune in sugar. The family patriarch, Carlos Pedro Blaquier, was charged in 2012 with unlawful detention over his suspected involvement in the "disappearance" of left-wing political activists; he died before standing trial. Sotheby's and Christie's fought fiercely to secure the estate — auction houses depend on such estate sales for profit as the market slowly recovers from a yearslong recession.
Is this an isolated case for Sotheby's?
No. Earlier this month, a Paris court ordered Sotheby's to nullify its sale of a 1902 Camille Pissarro and return it to heirs of Jewish banker Salomon Flavian, whose collection the Nazis seized in 1941. Over the summer, the federal government confiscated a Martian meteorite from Sotheby's after Justice Department officials flagged misleading customs paperwork, flawed provenance and an intermediary seller with a criminal record.
Several experts also point to attrition in Sotheby's restitution department: its leading expert, Lucien Simmons, left in 2024 after nearly three decades to become the Met Museum's head of provenance.
How has the law shifted?
Restitution rules have moved in heirs' favor. This year Congress passed legislation extending the Holocaust Expropriated Art Recovery Act, adding language that gives families extra time to file claims. Guidelines have also loosened in countries like the United States and the Netherlands.
"The law has evolved to accept the principle that if you were forced — even if you were out of Germany but still had no choice but to sell the asset — it is still considered a sale under duress and the result of Nazi persecution," explained Sam Dubbin, a lawyer who has represented Jewish families in restitution disputes but is not involved in this case.
Auction experts agree the painting might struggle to find a buyer with the doubt hanging over it, though some think it's a risk worth taking for such a rare work. "A potential buyer would need to do due diligence on the universe of potential claimants," Dubbin said. Monday's meeting in Manhattan will show whether Sotheby's can settle that question before the hammer falls on Wednesday.
Source: NYT Arts
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Correspondent covering technology and product news in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,537 articles



