On viewArt Market

Sotheby's Defends $180M Van Gogh Sale Against Nazi-Era Claim

Heirs of Samuel Fischer demand Sotheby's withdraw the $180M 'Châtaigniers en fleurs' from its November 18 sale, citing Nazi-era duress. Sotheby's cites 1936 records.

Sotheby’s $180 M. Van Gogh Sale Faces Eleventh-Hour Nazi-Era Restitution Claim
Sotheby’s $180 M. Van Gogh Sale Faces Eleventh-Hour Nazi-Era Restitution ClaimCouleur / pixabay

Programme

  1. Van Gogh's 'Châtaigniers en fleurs' (1890) carries a $180 million estimate and is scheduled for Sotheby's November 18 auction.
  2. Sotheby's says Cassirer archives show the painting sold in June 1936 for 68,000 Swiss francs (about $22,000).
  3. The Fischer heirs' claim arrived November 12, five days before the sale.
  4. The 12-painting Blaquier-Arrieta collection is expected to bring around $450 million.
  5. A 2025 HEAR Act amendment eliminated the laches delay defense for restitution claims.

A $180 million Vincent van Gogh is due under the hammer Wednesday at Sotheby's, and the auction house is pushing back against a last-minute restitution claim with new details about a 1936 sale. Sotheby's says archives of the dealer Paul Cassirer confirm that Châtaigniers en fleurs (1890), also known as Blossoming Chestnut Trees, sold for 68,000 Swiss francs — about $22,000 — in June 1936. The house calls that a strong price for a van Gogh at the time. For comparison: Verger avec cyprès (1888), which fetched $117.2 million at Christie's in 2022 from the Paul Allen collection, sold at Parke-Bernet in 1935 for $15,000.

The New York Times reported Friday that the heirs of Samuel Fischer, a Jewish publisher whose family fled Nazi Germany, asked Sotheby's to withdraw the painting from its November 18 auction. They say financial pressure caused by Nazi persecution forced the family to sell.

Their lawyer, Gunnar Schnabel, challenged Sotheby's to prove the family received fair market value and would have sold the picture even without the Nazis. "Otherwise," he wrote, "no auction may take place." He added that his client "is prepared to work toward a fair and just solution under the Washington Principles," the international guidelines for Nazi-looted art claims. Schnabel did not respond to ARTnews before publication.

What does the 1936 sale record show?

Samuel Fischer, who died in 1934, founded one of Germany's most important publishing houses, publishing Thomas Mann and Hermann Hesse. The family moved the business to Vienna in 1936 and fled after the 1938 annexation. The Gestapo seized their Vienna home, library and remaining art.

The van Gogh's path differs. Provenance records show the family placed it with Cassirer's Amsterdam gallery in 1932 or 1933, alongside two Cézannes. It sat on consignment for nearly three years, traveled to Rotterdam and Bern for exhibitions, and was sold in the Netherlands — outside Nazi control.

Luke Nikas, a lawyer for Sotheby's, said the painting went to an independent buyer at fair market value. "The family had pursued and recovered works from the 1938 forced sale, but never the works they sold in 1936, such as this van Gogh," Nikas said. He cited a postwar brochure by Gottfried Bermann Fischer listing paintings the family wanted back; he has seen the document, and the van Gogh is not in it.

The Cézannes add context. One hangs at the Harvard Art Museums without any heir claim. The other sold at Christie's in 2017 for almost $6 million; in 2007, Gisela Bermann Fischer, who handled the family's claims until her death in 2014, told Christie's she would not oppose the sale — while reserving the right to challenge sales she believed were made under duress. Sotheby's said it reviewed the 2007 sale but did not know of that reservation, contained in confidential correspondence.

What does the law change for restitution claims?

Nikas pointed to two Picasso cases: Zuckerman v. Metropolitan Museum of Art, dismissed in 2018 and upheld in 2019, and Bennigson v. Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation, dismissed in 2024 and upheld in 2025 — both partly because heirs waited too long.

Congress changed that calculus in April. Lawmakers amended the HEAR Act, eliminating the laches defense that let courts toss claims over delay. New York art lawyer Judd Grossman, uninvolved in the dispute, told ARTnews: "With this year's amendments to the HEAR Act eliminating the equitable laches defense... the pendulum has swung dramatically in favor of claimants regardless of whether they have ever taken steps to vindicate their rights." He predicted "more of this sort of gamesmanship by claimants waiting to the very last minute." The amendment does not change what counts as a forced sale.

Schnabel is no newcomer. A 2022 federal court opinion recounts how he and researcher Monika Tatzkow approached Mondrian's heirs in 2016, research that led to a claim against the Philadelphia Museum of Art. Sotheby's says it first heard from Fischer representatives on Thursday, November 12 — more than six weeks after the sale was publicized in early October, and five days before the auction.

The van Gogh anchors the 12-work Blaquier-Arrieta collection of Argentine collectors Carlos Pedro Blaquier and Nelly Arrieta de Blaquier, estimated at around $450 million. Christie's also bid for the guarantee. The Blaquier family said in a statement it "welcomes constructive dialogue with the Fischer heirs and supports efforts to reach a mutually satisfactory resolution." Whether that happens before Wednesday remains to be seen.

Original: nytimes.com

vincent-van-gogh, sotheby-s, nazi-looted-art, restitution-claims, art-auctions

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »