Film & Screen

The Love Hypothesis Review: Fake Dating, Reliable Returns

Lili Reinhart and Tom Bateman test a fake relationship in The Love Hypothesis. The experiment yields steady, expected results for the genre.

‘The Love Hypothesis’ Review: Steady Results From a Fake Relationship
‘The Love Hypothesis’ Review: Steady Results From a Fake RelationshipAI-generated

The Love Hypothesis arrives with a premise as old as the genre itself: a fake relationship entered for reasons of principle. Lili Reinhart plays a biology graduate student. Tom Bateman plays a young professor. Together they conduct an experiment in deception, and the film follows the results with professional steadiness.

The setup, as the production describes it, is straightforward. Reinhart's graduate student enters the arrangement with Bateman's professor to prove a point to her friend. That single motive drives the plot. Everything else — the pretending, the proximity, the inevitable blurring of the hypothetical and the actual — flows from it.

Reinhart carries the central role. Her casting gives the film its most recognizable face, and the material asks of her exactly what fake-dating narratives always ask: skepticism in act one, ambivalence in act two, capitulation by the finale. Bateman, as the professor, operates on the other side of the equation. The power dynamic between a graduate student and a faculty member gives the premise its edge — the film's scientific framing, with its hypothesis and its experiment, is doing quiet work to soften it.

The title itself signals the conceit. A hypothesis is proposed, tested, and either confirmed or rejected. The Love Hypothesis applies that structure to romance: two people who insist their arrangement is research discover, in the standard way, that the data refuses to cooperate. The biology setting is not incidental. It places the characters in a world where feelings are supposed to be controlled variables, which is precisely the world this genre exists to disrupt.

What distinguishes the film, on the evidence available, is its temperament. The results are steady. The review's verdict implies competence rather than surprise — a film that sets a modest hypothesis, runs the experiment cleanly, and reports the expected findings. In a romantic-comedy market crowded with uneven attempts, consistency is its own achievement.

That steadiness will likely define the audience's response. Viewers seeking subversion of the fake-relationship formula will not find it here. Viewers seeking the formula executed with a reliable lead performance, a workable pairing, and a clear through-line from fake to real will get exactly that. The film knows what it is testing for.

The graduate-student-professor pairing also gives Reinhart a character with stated intellectual stakes. She enters the experiment to make an argument, not merely to fill a slot in a plot. That grounding matters in a genre so often criticized for weightless motivation. Her point — the one the experiment exists to prove to her friend — remains the engine of the story.

Where the film lands within its genre depends finally on execution the premise alone cannot guarantee. But the elements named here — Reinhart's presence, Bateman's casting, the laboratory setting, the single clean motive — suggest a production that understood its assignment. The Love Hypothesis proposes that fake love becomes real love. The film's steady results confirm the field's longest-standing finding.

Source: NYT Arts

Share this article:

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Correspondent covering media and advertising at Arts & Voices.

More from Grace Kim →