On viewMuseums & Exhibitions

Artists Should Get Tax Breaks for Donating Works to UK Museums

A new Cultural Policy Unit report urges UK tax breaks for artists donating works to museums, citing 15 years of declining arts funding and a philanthropy gap versus Europe and the US.

Artists should receive tax breaks for donating their own work to UK museums, says new philanthropy report
Artists should receive tax breaks for donating their own work to UK museums, says new philanthropy reportAurélien-Barre / pixabay

Programme

  1. The Cultural Policy Unit published 'A National Strategy for Cultural Philanthropy' on 18 November 2024-style Wednesday 18 November
  2. The report proposes tax recognition for artists donating their own works, based on independent valuation
  3. UK government arts funding has declined as public finances tightened over the last 15 years, the CPU says
  4. The National Gallery's Domani project secured £375m from Crankstart and the Julia Rausing Trust
  5. Other proposals include a King's Philanthropy Medal for Culture and a regional match-and-seed funding programme

Artists who donate their own works to UK museums and galleries should receive tax breaks based on independent valuation, according to a new report published on Wednesday 18 November by the think tank The Cultural Policy Unit (CPU).

The proposal is one of several "tax enabling" measures in the report, "A National Strategy for Cultural Philanthropy", which argues that philanthropy "should be treated as both an urgent [UK] strategic priority and a deliberate instrument of cultural policy".

The CPU's diagnosis is blunt: "public finances have tightened considerably over the last 15 years, government funding for the arts has declined and self-generated income, while a key area, has not succeeded in plugging the widening gap."

What else does the report propose?

The wide-ranging recommendations include:

  • Tax recognition for artists donating their own works to qualifying cultural institutions, based on independent valuation
  • Simplified inheritance tax rules to protect charitable giving through estate planning
  • Clearer VAT rules around cultural donations
  • A King's Philanthropy Medal for Culture
  • A national cultural "match-and-seed funding" programme with a regional focus

Alison Cole, the CPU's director and former editor of The Art Newspaper, said: "While the arts funding environment has changed dramatically in recent years, the philanthropic landscape has hardly kept pace let alone filled the gap with the UK lagging far behind the incentives offered by many of our European and US counterparts. We need a new national strategy that not only identifies the opportunities and need, but also thrives on a spirit of creative collaboration and mutual respect."

How do UK incentives compare abroad?

The report acknowledges that existing schemes — Gift Aid, Acceptance in Lieu and the Cultural Gifts Scheme — have delivered real benefits, but says they should be enhanced so donors are more aware of them. UK incentives are "broadly generous, but they are structured very differently from overseas models", the report states. "The practical result is that British donors give quietly and anonymously, while the US and other systems reward public foundations and naming opportunities."

Charles Saumarez Smith, who previously led the National Gallery, the National Portrait Gallery and the Royal Academy, called the report "sensible". "I particularly appreciated the information as to how other countries encourage philanthropy, not just the US," he told The Art Newspaper. "The biggest issue seems to me to be the lack of clarity round the existing systems, including, for example, around inheritance. How many people, even within cultural institutions, knows how this operates?"

Not everyone endorses the US example wholesale. Kate Rolfe, a cultural strategy consultant, agrees that "new incentives are needed" but warns against "following the US model too closely". "It can change the decision-making dynamic internally and make it harder to follow an organisational vision," she says. "I also think corporate donations need to be reincentivised, as these often lead to really creative partnerships based on shared audiences and values."

What does this change for museums?

For now, nothing is guaranteed. The report is a set of proposals, not policy, and there is no indication in it of government endorsement or a legislative timetable. What it does offer institutions is evidence of a widening funding gap and a template for closing it.

"Focused giving" may point one way forward. The report cites the Domani project at the National Gallery in London, which secured £375m from Crankstart — the charitable foundation of Sir Michael Moritz and his wife Harriet Heyman — and the Julia Rausing Trust for a new Modern art wing. Cole's caveat is deliberate: "The real transformation needs to be across the country and not just in the capital."

Source: theartnewspaper.com

cultural-philanthropy, tax-incentives, museum-funding, art-donations, uk-arts-policy

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »