On viewLiterature

Michelle Tea's 'Free Love' Makes the Case for Marriage, Multiplied

Michelle Tea's 'Free Love' (HarperOne, 2026) traces a $19.99 witch wedding, Gay Shame's marriage wars, and asks whether polyamory and matrimony can finally coexist.

The More, the Merrier: Michelle Tea On the Possibilities of Polyamory
The More, the Merrier: Michelle Tea On the Possibilities of PolyamoryJonathan Borba / unsplash

Programme

  1. Michelle Tea's 'Free Love: Adventures in Marriage and Polyamory' is published by HarperOne, copyright 2026.
  2. Tea's first marriage, to Aldo in 2000, was performed by a witch for $19.99 and held no legal status.
  3. Courts in 2018 rejected a throuple's bid to use John Roberts's Obergefell dissent to claim a right to plural marriage.
  4. Tea and her spouse studied Eve Rickert and Franklin Veaux's 'More Than Two' as a manual for opening their marriage.
  5. A 2012 University of British Columbia study argued monogamy's advantage over polygyny is 'the more egalitarian distribution of women.'

Michelle Tea's new book 'Free Love: Adventures in Marriage and Polyamory,' published by HarperOne in 2026, opens with a wedding that carried no legal weight. In 2000, Tea eloped with her trans boyfriend Aldo, married by a witch named Jo-Jo whose fee was $19.99 — part of which went toward a sheet cake from Safeway.

The ceremony happened after a Bingo party that was, Tea notes wryly, technically an illicit gambling ring, held in the queer punk household where she spent her twenties. Her wedding dress came from a street vendor; her veil was a ribbon crown with fake butterflies from Target's children's department.

What does the book actually argue? Tea's central claim is that opening a marriage can strengthen it rather than dissolve it. 'Opening up a marriage pushes you to look at your spouse as a freaky and unique individual, not an extension of your own self,' she writes. Her own marriage to Aldo lasted seven years, and its final, nonmonogamous months were, she says, among its best — even though Aldo ultimately left for a monogamous relationship with someone else.

The memoir situates that personal story inside a larger queer history. At the turn of the century, the San Francisco activist collective Gay Shame attacked the push for gay marriage as assimilation. Co-founder Mattilda Bernstein Sycamore wrote that 'the gay elite has hijacked queer struggle, and positioned their desires as everyone's needs.' The group argued resources should go toward police brutality, affordable housing, and violence against sex workers and trans people instead. Gay Shame faded, reemerged in 2013 around prison abolition and anti-gentrification work, and Tea admits she kept her distance, fearing a 'purity test I was bound to fail.'

Her own position was contrarian on both sides: 'I was for gay marriage so that I could abuse it, like heterosexuals do,' she liked to say — eight marriages, Elizabeth Taylor-style.

From Big Love to More Than Two

Tea credits HBO's 2006 Mormon polygamy drama 'Big Love,' and specifically Chloë Sevigny's Nicki, with influencing her and Aldo's decision to open their marriage. Later, as a polyamorous married mother, she and her spouse worked through Eve Rickert and Franklin Veaux's guidebook 'More Than Two' each morning — a marriage that also ended in divorce, though not before a practical lesson stuck: when she felt jealous of her spouse's girlfriend, she asked for concert tickets rather than issuing rules.

The book also engages the legal record. During the 2015 Supreme Court cases, Justice Samuel Alito wondered how a state permitting queer marriage could logically deny a mixed-gender foursome, and Chief Justice John Roberts wrote that the majority's logic 'would apply with equal force to the claim of a fundamental right to plural marriage.' In 2018, courts rejected a throuple's attempt to use that dissent to win legal group marriage.

A 2012 University of British Columbia study concluded that monogamy's 'main cultural evolutionary advantage over polygyny is the more egalitarian distribution of women.' Tea won't defend patriarchal polygyny, but she objects to the framing itself: women described as objects to be distributed among men.

The book closes with Mara, a Brooklyn playwright born in Puerto Rico, who wants to marry both her partners. 'At the end of the day, it's so comforting and relaxing to have these two beautiful souls share themselves and share me,' Mara says. barred from legal marriage, she settles on a workaround: 'Maybe we'll just have a huge party!'

Original: bookshop.org

michelle-tea, free-love, polyamory, queer-marriage, non-monogamy

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »