On viewTheatre

The Fantasticks reaches Broadway with Matt, Lewis and meddling mothers

Nathan Levy and Maxim Chlumecky play Matt and Lewis in Christopher Gattelli’s Broadway staging, where two fathers become meddling mothers and Tom Jones revises the libretto.

The Cast of The Fantasticks on Its Broadway Reinvention
The Cast of The Fantasticks on Its Broadway ReinventionPapafox / pixabay

Programme

  1. Christopher Gattelli directed and choreographed the new Broadway production of The Fantasticks.
  2. Nathan Levy plays Lewis, and Maxim Chlumecky plays Matt.
  3. The central couple changed from Matt and Luisa to Matt and Lewis.
  4. Two fathers were recast as a pair of meddling mothers.
  5. Tom Jones revised the libretto, while Gattelli praised the writing’s creativity, storytelling and heart.

Nathan Levy plays Lewis and Maxim Chlumecky plays Matt in Christopher Gattelli’s new Broadway production of The Fantasticks. The staging revises two central relationships: Matt and Luisa have become Matt and Lewis, while their two fathers have become a pair of meddling mothers.

Gattelli serves as director and choreographer. Broadway.com describes the Tony-winning showman as the creative force behind Schmigadoon! and Death Becomes Her. Its opening-night conversation with the cast and Gattelli focused on the show’s “enduring appeal and universal themes.”

What changes in the new staging?

Lewis replaces Luisa, the central couple becomes Matt and Lewis, and two fathers become two meddling mothers, making the revised relationships the production’s clearest departures from the existing material.

Gattelli framed those alterations within Tom Jones’s revisions to the libretto. “I think it's such a testament to great writing, the fact that you could just change a couple pronouns, but basically everything is the same and it still works. It speaks to their creativity and their storytelling and their heart. The show has so much heart.”

For Gattelli, that claim carries particular weight because the production’s changes are immediately legible. One member of the central couple changes gender, and both parental roles change from father to mother. Yet his praise rests on continuity, treating the adaptation as a test of the writing’s durability.

Why did Levy take Lewis?

Levy framed his casting as a reversal of expectation. “I'm still pinching myself. This was never a show or a role I ever thought was possible for me,” he said.

He tied that surprise to the show’s place in a specific city. “[The Fantasticks is] in the DNA of New York musical theater, so it only makes sense that this is how we're bringing it to Broadway. I'm just the luckiest guy.”

The new staging places Levy opposite Chlumecky as the central couple. That casting also puts an actor describing the role as impossible inside the production’s claim to renew a familiar show for a new generation.

Levy’s surprise and Gattelli’s conviction offer two measures of the same risk. The first tests a performer’s connection to an altered role. The second tests the writing’s ability to retain its emotional force. The revival therefore depends on both a personal performance and a durable script.

What does Gattelli bring to the revival?

Gattelli’s credits include Schmigadoon! and Death Becomes Her, the works Broadway.com used to identify the Tony-winning showman. On The Fantasticks, he combines direction and choreography with a flexible view of adaptation.

His comments on Jones’s libretto revisions made authorship central to that leadership: he credited the writer’s creativity, storytelling and heart for the show’s ability to absorb changed pronouns without losing its dramatic identity.

The production asks him to preserve continuity while changing the relationships most likely to affect its tone. That combination defines his stated task. His claim puts the burden on the staging to make continuity visible rather than merely announce it.

Can the reinvention retain the show’s heart?

Broadway.com presented the production as both a preservation of a “beloved romantic comedy” and a recasting for a new generation. Those aims pull in opposite directions: the show must remain recognizable enough to retain its established appeal, yet differ enough to justify the new relationships.

The audience must still recognize the romantic comedy while meeting Lewis in place of Luisa and two meddling mothers in place of fathers. The Broadway run will test whether Levy and Chlumecky can make those changes newly legible while Gattelli preserves the “heart” he found in Jones’s writing.

Source: broadway.com

the-fantasticks, broadway, nathan-levy, christopher-gattelli, musical-theatre

Also on view

« Previous article