On viewVisual Arts

New Hopper Biography Reveals Copies, Rivalry and a Marriage in Paint

The first Edward Hopper biography in 30 years draws on nearly 100 unpublished Jo Hopper notebooks, revealing copied early oils and a marriage of rivalry and neglect.

‘His lighthouses are self-portraits’: did Edward Hopper paint his sexual problems?
‘His lighthouses are self-portraits’: did Edward Hopper paint his sexual problems?ptra / pixabay

Programme

  1. The first Edward Hopper biography in 30 years, and only the second ever, draws on Jo Hopper's 35 years of diaries and almost 100 notebooks.
  2. All of Hopper's earliest oils, long claimed as originals, are copies from Victorian periodical colour reproductions.
  3. Hopper's most-painted subject was a lighthouse at Two Lights, Maine; Jo wrote in 1946: 'Those lighthouses are self-portraits.'
  4. Jo Hopper wrote in 1923 she encouraged Edward to paint watercolours, leading to a landmark sale and his lifetime gallerist.
  5. Hopper's final oil, Two Comedians (1966), finally depicted Jo as an equal partner.

By Marcus Bennett

In 1950, the Whitney Museum of American Art staged an Edward Hopper retrospective, and the catalogue deleted three words: "the artist". The phrase had described Josephine Nivison Hopper, the painter Edward married in 1924. "I'm not allowed to exist even in my husband's biography," Jo seethed in a private notebook that has just come to light. "And that's all right with EH."

The notebook is one of many unpublished documents anchoring the first biography of Edward Hopper in 30 years, and only the second ever. Jo, a self-confessed "pack-rat", left 35 years of daily diaries, almost 100 notebooks, reels of letters and four ledger books documenting Edward's works. Much of the archive is housed at the Whitney. She preserved everything from film and theatre ticket stubs to magazines, catalogues and photographs. She once considered writing her husband's biography herself, then abandoned the plan: "To have to think and weigh and be explicit – this big, tall, lonely, silent man … it would need expert reporting and memory to repeat his exact words for any fairness."

What does the new material reveal?

One notebook spanning nearly 80 pages records the abuse Jo suffered, their unsatisfactory sex life, and the farce of their wedding day. Edward, who was not baptised, was turned away by a reverend, and the couple rushed from church to church, losing their best man along the way.

The biography also upends a foundational myth. All of Edward's earliest oils, long claimed as originals and some supposedly depicting his home town of Nyack in upstate New York, are in fact copies from colour reproductions of other artists' works in Victorian periodicals, complete with copying instructions. The discovery shows Hopper engaging with the American art of his era from an early age, not emerging from a vacuum.

Why did Hopper paint lighthouses?

It is still little-recognised that most of Hopper's paintings depict regional subjects, largely in New England, rather than the cityscapes he is known for. His most-painted subject was a lighthouse in the remote Maine village of Two Lights. The Hoppers drove there in the summer of 1927. "We fell in love with the lighthouse," Jo wrote. When she attempted "a harmless little watercolour", Edward huffed: "If you're going to paint it – I won't." Jo sulked on the rocks, compiling a list of "blessings of attributes of E to be remembered in times of stress". It did little to redeem a husband she called a "sadist" and a "prize hog".

At 6ft 4in tall, Edward repeatedly implied that the awkward, tall architectures in his paintings were anthropomorphic self-portraits. In 1946, Jo wrote: "Those lighthouses are self-portraits." She added: "That ego is impenetrable … It was pitiful to see all the poor dead birds that had run into [the lighthouses] on a dark night. I know just how they felt. That bright light on the top had deceived them."

For Edward, though, 1929's The Lighthouse at Two Lights was as close to celebratory as his art came. Cherishing Walt Whitman and Ralph Waldo Emerson, he envisaged the lighthouse as a beacon of American individualism. His New England icons also fed a fiercely nationalist, isolationist press hungry for the regional "American scene". Critics labelled his work "Anglo-Saxon" and "Puritan" for decades. Edward capitalised on it, telling one critic: "You did a swell job on me as a Puritan."

The 1928 self-portrait Captain Ed Staples – a New England sea captain, destroyed in a 1929 train crash – embodies the pose. Ancestral records show the Staples family co-founded Two Lights and befriended the Hoppers.

What happened to Jo's career?

As Edward's fortunes rose in the late 1920s, Jo's dwindled. She had enjoyed success in modernist circles, and in 1923 she encouraged Edward to paint watercolours, leading to a landmark sale and the securing of his lifetime gallerist. Edward almost never helped her in return. Female artists, she wrote, were to him "nil – zero minus etc".

His paintings registered the strain. In Four Lane Road, a woman leans from a gas-station window, mouth open, disturbing a man seated outside who resembles Captain Ed Staples. Jo saw Edward "making the most evil face on the woman at window … a regular shrike, expressive of what he's feeling about me". Her ledger entry reads: "Woman … finds his serenity a trial."

The 1959 Excursion into Philosophy shows a woman on a bed, turned away, naked buttocks displayed beside an open book that echoes their shape. Jo, who called Edward's sexual preferences "attacks from the rear", described it as a "book of Plato … resorted to on morning after episode with young woman". Jo also modelled for the 1941 Girlie Show, a nude burlesque performer she variously named "minx", "vixen" and "siren". On a stray scrap of paper she recorded the experience: "One doesn't exist at all in any personal sense. He isn't painting you. He raves about the wall … Little does he care how you freeze."

Edward's final oil, Two Comedians (1966), at last acknowledged Jo as an equal partner: the couple as Pierrot and Pierrette, holding hands and bowing out, a nod to their favourite film, Les Enfants du Paradis (1945). "This marriage has been the one great enterprise – my kingdom come," Jo wrote in 1939. The biography now ensures that kingdom had two subjects, not one.

Source: theguardian.com

edward-hopper, josephine-nivison-hopper, artist-biography, american-art, whitney-museum-of-american-art

Also on view

« Previous article