On viewArt Market

Sotheby's settles Van Gogh dispute before $180m New York sale

Sotheby's will sell Van Gogh's Blossoming Chestnut Trees in New York on 18 November after the Fischer heirs and the Blaquier-Arrieta family settled their claim over the painting's 1936 sale.

Sotheby's makes last-minute deal to sell $180m Van Gogh painting following dispute
Sotheby's makes last-minute deal to sell $180m Van Gogh painting following disputeYlanite / pixabay

Programme

  1. Sotheby's guarantees Blossoming Chestnut Trees (May 1890) to sell for around $180 million, or $207 million with fees, in New York on 18 November.
  2. On 12 November, Gunnar Schnabel wrote to Sotheby's for the Fischer heirs, questioning the painting's 1936 sale to Henriette and Marcel Kapferer and asking for a delay.
  3. The previous Van Gogh record is $117 million, paid at Christie's in 2022 for Orchard with Cypresses (April 1888).
  4. Samuel and Hedwig Fischer acquired the painting in 1909; the Blaquier-Arrieta family of Argentina bought it in 1975.
  5. The terms of the settlement and any financial compensation for the Fischer family remain undisclosed.

Sotheby's will sell Vincent van Gogh's Blossoming Chestnut Trees (Châtaigniers en fleurs) in New York on 18 November. The auction house values the May 1890 painting at around $180 million, or $207 million with fees, and has guaranteed it to sell.

A settlement reached this week removes the last obstacle to that sale. The Fischer heirs, who represent the painting's Jewish former owners, had asked Sotheby's to withdraw the work from the auction after questioning its 1936 sale. Sotheby's had expected the picture to set a record for the artist.

The auction house confirmed the agreement in a statement:

“pleased to confirm that an agreement has been reached between the Blaquier-Arrieta family and all of the legal descendants of Hedwig and Samuel Fischer regarding the sale of Vincent van Gogh's Châtaigniers en fleurs”.

The statement said the sale will now proceed as planned.

What does the settlement change?

It secures the sale. The $207 million estimate with fees stands well above the previous record of $117 million, paid at Christie's in 2022 for Van Gogh's Orchard with Cypresses (April 1888).

It does not explain how the two families resolved their disagreement. Sotheby's has not released the terms of the agreement, and no details have emerged on whether the Fischer family will receive financial compensation. Any effect of the short-lived dispute will show only in the bidding.

What triggered the withdrawal demand?

On 12 November, Gunnar Schnabel, a Berlin-based restitution researcher (a specialist tracing the wartime displacement of Jewish-owned artworks), wrote to Sotheby's on behalf of the Fischer heirs. Schnabel questioned the 1936 sale, which he says took place three months after the family had left Berlin for Vienna.

He asked Sotheby's to prove that the picture had sold at its market value and that the sale had not been forced. Schnabel also asked for that week's sale to be delayed.

How did the painting reach the Blaquier-Arrieta family?

The Sotheby's catalogue entry has noted the provenance since last month. It records that the Berlin publisher Samuel Fischer and his wife Hedwig acquired the painting in 1909. Their son-in-law, Gottfried Bermann Fischer, deposited the Van Gogh with the Amsterdam gallery Paul Cassirer in 1932 or 1933.

Henriette and Marcel Kapferer, Paris collectors, bought the work in 1936. The Blaquier-Arrieta family, from Argentina, acquired it in 1975.

What did the two families say?

Sotheby's framed the outcome as an acknowledgment of history rather than a financial deal:

“In recognition of the painting's complex Nazi-era history and the suffering endured by the Fischer family during the Holocaust, the two families have reached a mutually satisfactory resolution and the work will be sold pursuant to their agreement.”

The Fischer heirs said:

“We are grateful for the trusting and fair negotiation and collaboration with Sotheby's and the Blaquier-Arrieta family, which make it possible to acknowledge the suffering of the Fischer family during the Nazi era and honour Gisela Berman Fischer's [granddaughter of Samuel and Hedwig] history of seeking justice for her family.”

The Blaquier-Arrieta family said:

“We are pleased to have reached an amicable resolution with the Fischer heirs. We appreciate the constructive dialogue that made this resolution possible and look forward to an extraordinary result and to passing along this masterpiece to a new generation of collectors.”

What does the auction now test?

For buyers, the practical question is simple: the painting sells on 18 November, at a price the house has guaranteed. For heirs and restitution researchers, the test is how far the price reaches against the $117 million record, and what the undisclosed terms of the settlement will mean for future cases.

Martin Bailey will analyse the sale result in his weekly Adventures with Van Gogh blog on Friday. The hammer will supply the number. The terms of the agreement remain the harder record to read.

Source: theartnewspaper.com

vincent-van-gogh, sotheby-s, art-restitution, fine-art-auctions, blossoming-chestnut-trees

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »